Books like The Starless Sea
What should you read after Erin Morgenstern’s novel? It depends on what you loved most about it.
- Erin Morgenstern
- 2019
- Fantasy
What did you love about it?
Choosing one reorders everything below.
Best books to read after The Starless Sea
Ranked overall. Pick what you loved above to re-rank them.
Best overall matchThe Night Circus
Erin Morgenstern
Same author, same instinct: build a place so specific you can smell the caramel, then let the plot amble. If the Starless Sea worked on you as a location, go straight here.
- Atmosphere over plot
- A secret society with initiations
- Love found across time
- Structure is far more conventional
Best for doors and the books about themThe Ten Thousand Doors of January
Alix E. Harrow
Harrow's doors do what Morgenstern's do — open where no door should be — and she nests a whole second book inside the first, so you get the stories-within-stories pleasure too.
- Doors painted on walls
- Stories nested inside stories
- Books that know you are reading
- Much tighter plotting
Best for the library itselfThe Library of the Unwritten
A. J. Hackwith
A library in Hell holding every book nobody finished writing, and characters who escape their drafts. The same premise Morgenstern circles, played much more briskly.
- An underground library of stories
- Books that know you are reading
- Stories nested inside stories
- Snappier, more genre-forward voice
Best for the love across centuriesThe Invisible Life of Addie LaRue
V.E. Schwab
A woman nobody can remember, and the one person who does. Schwab shares Morgenstern's belief that being written down is the only durable form of existing.
- Love found across time
- Atmosphere over plot
- Books that know you are reading
- Straightforwardly linear structure
Great matchThe Shadow of the Wind
Carlos Ruiz Zafón
It opens in a hidden library of forgotten books and never fully leaves it. Post-war Barcelona replaces the underground sea, and the mystery is tighter than anything Morgenstern attempts.
- An underground library of stories
- Stories nested inside stories
- Atmosphere over plot
- A mystery with a real solution
Worth a look — with a warningThe Magicians
Lev Grossman
Also about a young man who finds the door and discovers that arriving somewhere magical does not make him happy — but Grossman is acid where Morgenstern is honeyed.
- Doors painted on walls
- A secret society with initiations
- Atmosphere over plot
- Sour, cynical tone throughout
Great matchCirce
Madeline Miller
For the reader who loved the fables between chapters more than the frame story. Miller writes myth with that same hush, and gives it a spine the fragments never had.
- Love found across time
- Atmosphere over plot
- Stories nested inside stories
- One narrator, one line of time
Best for footnotes and invented loreJonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell
Susanna Clarke
Clarke buries an entire fictional scholarship in the footnotes of her own novel — the exact pleasure of the Starless Sea's interleaved fragments, sustained for eight hundred pages.
- Stories nested inside stories
- An underground library of stories
- Atmosphere over plot
- Enormous and deliberately slow
Best for the world under the worldNeverwhere
Neil Gaiman
An ordinary man falls through the floor of his own city into a place with its own courts, markets and rules. The Starless Sea's descent, done as a brisk adventure.
- Doors painted on walls
- An underground library of stories
- Atmosphere over plot
- Adventure plotting, not dream logic
Great matchThe Golem and the Jinni
Helene Wecker
Wecker shares the trick of dropping old fables into a real city and letting them wander, and the long inset tale of the jinni's past is the best kind of story-within-a-story.
- Stories nested inside stories
- Love found across time
- Atmosphere over plot
- Realist surface, patient pacing
Best for fairy tales as source materialThe Once and Future Witches
Alix E. Harrow
Harrow opens each chapter with a rewritten nursery rhyme and treats old stories as instructions rather than decoration — Morgenstern's reverence for tales, with a political engine.
- Stories nested inside stories
- A secret society with initiations
- Books that know you are reading
- Angry and pointedly political
Great matchThe Hazel Wood
Melissa Albert
A girl discovers her grandmother's out-of-print fairy tales are a real place, and that being a character in one is not a compliment. Dark, and the inset tales are the best part.
- Books that know you are reading
- Stories nested inside stories
- Doors painted on walls
- Young adult voice
Worth a look — with a warningThe Secret History
Donna Tartt
Here purely for the closed circle of students with private rites and a language of their own; strip out every fantastical element and this is what remains of the secret-society pleasure.
- A secret society with initiations
- Atmosphere over plot
- No magic whatsoever
What should you read after The Starless Sea?
The Starless Sea by Erin Morgenstern works on several levels at once, and which book you should read next depends on which of those levels got you. For most readers the closest match is The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern — same author, same instinct: build a place so specific you can smell the caramel, then let the plot amble. If the Starless Sea worked on you as a location, go straight here.
If what stayed with you was doors painted on walls, read The Ten Thousand Doors of January by Alix E. Harrow instead: harrow's doors do what Morgenstern's do — open where no door should be — and she nests a whole second book inside the first, so you get the stories-within-stories pleasure too. The Library of the Unwritten by A. J. Hackwith is the other strong option — a library in Hell holding every book nobody finished writing, and characters who escape their drafts. The same premise Morgenstern circles, played much more briskly.
Loved something else?
Start from any book and we’ll build the list around your reasons.
Find my next book →NextBook is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program. We earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. It doesn’t affect which books we recommend or how we rank them.
More “what to read next” lists
- Books like 1984
- Books like 2312
- Books like A Clockwork Orange
- Books like A Darker Shade of Magic
- Books like A Gentleman in Moscow
- Books like A Little Life
- Books like A Man Called Ove
- Books like A Memory Called Empire
- Books like A Wrinkle in Time
- Books like All Systems Red
- Books like All the Bright Places
- Books like Altered Carbon